Toppower Asia home

Transformers

Transformer losses, efficiency rules and TCO: a buyer's guide

2500 kVA 33 kV to 415 V low-loss oil-immersed distribution transformer with copper windings in a product scene

A transformer has two kinds of loss. No-load (core) loss is present whenever the unit is energised. Load (copper) loss rises with the square of the current. Regulations cap these losses: the EU through Ecodesign Tier 2 in Regulation (EU) 2019/1783, the US through DOE efficiency levels in 10 CFR 431. Above the legal minimum, loss capitalisation with A and B factors tells you which offer costs least over the transformer's life.

Key takeaways

  • No-load loss runs 8,760 hours a year. On lightly loaded distribution transformers it is often the largest part of the lifetime cost of losses.
  • Total cost of ownership (TCO) = purchase price + A × P0 + B × Pk. A and B convert each kW of loss into money, using the energy price, operating hours, load profile and discount rate.
  • EU Tier 2 limits have applied since 1 July 2021. In the US, the 2024 DOE rule requires compliance from 23 April 2029, and DOE reopened the rule for comment in 2026.
  • Amorphous cores cut no-load loss sharply but are larger, heavier and louder. Whether they pay back depends on the A factor and on the regulation in your market.

What are no-load and load losses?

No-load loss (P0) is consumed in the core by hysteresis and eddy currents whenever the transformer is energised, whatever the load. It depends on the core steel grade, the flux density, the lamination thickness and how well the joints are built. It changes very little with load.

Load loss (Pk) is mainly I²R loss in the windings plus stray losses in the windings, clamps and tank. It is quoted at rated current and corrected to a reference temperature. At any other load it scales with the square of the per-unit load: at 50% load, load loss is a quarter of Pk.

Efficiency at a given load is:

η = (k × S × cos φ) / (k × S × cos φ + P0 + k² × Pk)

where k is the per-unit load and S is the rated power. Efficiency is highest at the load where load loss equals no-load loss, k = √(P0/Pk). On most distribution designs that point falls somewhere between 30% and 50% load. This is one reason regulators test efficiency at part load rather than at full load.

As an example, take a 1,000 kVA oil-immersed unit with P0 = 0.693 kW and Pk = 7.6 kW (the EU Tier 2 maximums for that rating). At 50% load and unity power factor, efficiency is 500 / (500 + 0.693 + 1.9) ≈ 99.48%. Peak efficiency occurs at about 30% load.

How are losses capitalised in a tender?

Utilities and large industrial buyers compare offers on total cost of ownership:

TCO = Price + A × P0 + B × Pk

  • A (currency per kW of no-load loss) is the present value of supplying 1 kW continuously for the evaluation period: A = energy cost × 8,760 h × PV factor. The PV factor is (1 − (1 + i)^−n) / i for discount rate i over n years. Utilities often add a demand or capacity charge.
  • B (currency per kW of load loss) is A multiplied by the loss load factor, which is roughly the mean of the per-unit load squared over the year. A transformer that runs at an RMS load of 50% has a loss load factor of about 0.25.

Make sure A and B appear in the enquiry. Without them, bidders design to the cheapest compliant loss level. With them, bidders can trade copper and steel against price, and you can rank offers on one number. The transformer RFQ checklist shows where to put these factors in the data sheet.

Worked TCO example

This example uses hypothetical prices, purely to show the method. The site is an industrial plant with a 1,000 kVA, 11/0.4 kV transformer. Energy costs USD 0.10/kWh, the discount rate is 8%, the evaluation period is 25 years and the RMS load is 50%.

  • PV factor = (1 − 1.08^−25) / 0.08 = 10.67
  • A = 0.10 × 8,760 × 10.67 ≈ USD 9,350 per kW
  • B = A × 0.5² ≈ USD 2,340 per kW
Offer X: Tier 2 minimum, CRGOOffer Y: low-loss design
Purchase price (hypothetical)USD 15,000USD 17,500
No-load loss P00.693 kW0.45 kW
Load loss Pk7.6 kW7.0 kW
A × P0USD 6,480USD 4,210
B × PkUSD 17,770USD 16,360
TCOUSD 39,250USD 38,070

Offer Y costs USD 2,500 more to buy but about USD 1,180 less over 25 years. If the transformer were lightly loaded, for example a solar step-up unit that sits idle every night, B would fall and A would dominate even more. In that case the low no-load design would win by a wider margin. If energy were cheap or the discount rate high, offer X could win. Run the numbers for your own site before you specify "low-loss" by default.

Two refinements are worth adding on real projects. Model load growth over the evaluation period, because B rises with the square of the load. Include the cost of the heat that losses add to an indoor room, since in a hot climate that heat has to be removed by air conditioning.

What do the EU Ecodesign Tier 2 rules require?

Commission Regulation (EU) No 548/2014, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2019/1783, sets mandatory loss limits for transformers placed on the EU market. Tier 1 applied from 1 July 2015. The stricter Tier 2 has applied since 1 July 2021.

  • Medium power transformers (all windings ≤ 3,150 kVA, Um above 1.1 kV and up to 36 kV) have maximum load and no-load losses for each kVA rating, with separate tables for liquid-immersed and dry-type units. Pole-mounted transformers have their own table.
  • Large power transformers (above 3,150 kVA or Um above 36 kV) must meet a minimum peak efficiency index (PEI).
  • The 2019 amendment clarified the rules for repaired transformers, correction factors for dual-voltage units, and exemptions. Exempt types include instrument, traction, furnace, offshore and some rectifier transformers.
Three-phase medium power transformerTier 2 liquid-immersed (Pk / P0)Tier 2 dry-type (Pk / P0)
630 kVA4,600 W / 540 W7,100 W / 990 W
1,000 kVA7,600 W / 693 W9,000 W / 1,395 W

Values for intermediate ratings are found by interpolation. The Commission has been reviewing the regulation, and a later tier with tighter values is expected. Check the legal text in force on the date the transformer is placed on the market, not the date of your enquiry.

What do the US DOE rules require?

In the US, distribution transformers must meet the minimum efficiencies in 10 CFR 431.196. Efficiency is measured at a defined per-unit load: 50% for liquid-immersed and medium-voltage dry-type units, and 35% for low-voltage dry-type units. Load loss is corrected to a reference temperature. The current levels date from 2016.

In April 2024 DOE published a final rule raising those levels, with compliance required from 23 April 2029. The final rule was softened from the 2023 proposal so that most units can still use grain-oriented electrical steel (GOES), while some classes are expected to move to amorphous cores. In June 2026 DOE asked for comments on whether to revise the rule, citing supply-chain and domestic-manufacturing concerns. Treat the 2029 levels as the legal requirement today, but confirm the status before you fix a design for delivery after 2028. Our IEC 60076 vs IEEE C57 comparison covers the other differences in the US market, and our pad-mounted transformers are offered to DOE efficiency levels on request.

What about other markets?

  • China: GB 20052-2024 replaced GB 20052-2020 from 1 February 2025. It sets energy efficiency grades for 10 kV distribution transformers, larger power transformers, and units used on the generation side of PV, wind and storage plants.
  • India: IS 1180 defines energy efficiency levels for distribution transformers, and BEE labelling applies to many ratings.
  • Australia and New Zealand: distribution transformers have been subject to minimum energy performance standards (MEPS) for many years.
  • Elsewhere: many utilities in Africa, the Middle East and Latin America have no national regulation but write loss limits or A/B factors into their own tender specifications. That makes the tender document the real "regulation" for the project.

For loss calculation methods, IEC TS 60076-20 describes the efficiency index approach that the EU regulation uses.

Amorphous core or CRGO?

CRGO / GOES coreAmorphous metal core
No-load lossBaseline; depends on steel grade (e.g. Hi-B, laser-scribed)Much lower, often less than half of a comparable CRGO design
Saturation flux densityHigher, so the core is more compactLower, so the core is larger and heavier
NoiseLower for the same ratingUsually higher; check sound limits
Mechanical sensitivityRobustBrittle ribbon; needs careful core support
Typical rangeAll ratings up to EHVMainly distribution ratings
Best fitHigh-load sites, low A factor, compact installationsLightly loaded networks, high A factor, strict no-load limits

Hi-B and laser-scribed CRGO already meet EU Tier 2 at most distribution ratings. Amorphous cores make sense when the A factor is high or a regulation pushes no-load loss very low. Our energy-saving oil distribution transformers and cast-resin dry-type range can be designed to a specified loss table. Dry-type units have higher losses than oil-immersed units at the same rating, which is one of the trade-offs explained in dry-type vs oil-immersed transformers.

Frequently asked questions

Which loss matters more, no-load or load?

It depends on the load profile. On a lightly loaded rural or solar transformer, no-load loss dominates because it runs every hour of the year. On a heavily loaded industrial unit, load loss usually costs more. A and B factors capture this automatically.

Does EU Tier 2 apply to transformers exported outside the EU?

No. Ecodesign applies only to products placed on the EU market. Many buyers outside the EU still use the Tier 2 tables as a ready-made loss specification, which is a sensible shortcut.

How are guaranteed losses verified?

They are verified by the routine load-loss and no-load-loss tests, corrected to the reference temperature. IEC 60076-1 allows +10% on total losses unless the contract says otherwise. A regulatory limit must be met without that tolerance. See routine tests before shipment.

Is a 99% efficient transformer always better?

Not necessarily. Efficiency at one load point does not tell you the lifetime cost. Compare offers on TCO using your own A and B values, and check that the design still meets impedance, sound and size limits.

Will the US 2029 rule change?

DOE opened a request for comments in June 2026, but as of this writing the April 2024 rule with its 23 April 2029 compliance date has not been replaced. Check the Federal Register before you fix a design for US delivery after 2028.

Send us your load profile, energy tariff and the regulation that applies, and we will propose designs with guaranteed losses and a TCO comparison. Contact the Toppower Asia engineering team with your single-line diagram or transformer specification.

Toppower Asia Engineering Team

Application and sales engineers at Shanghai Toppower-Asia Co., Ltd. who review specifications and prepare technical proposals for transformers, switchgear, substations and battery storage. Questions about this article: kevin@toppower-asia.com.

More on transformers

Send your single-line diagram. Get a technical proposal back.

Tell us the rating, voltages and site. Our engineers review it against your network before pricing, and reply with ratings, losses, dimensions, test scope and a quotation.

Rated power, voltages, frequency, standard, site conditions and destination port help us reply with a firm proposal.

Send via WhatsApp

Replies come from kevin@toppower-asia.com. Office hours are Monday to Friday, 9:00–18:00 China Standard Time.

Press Enter to see all matching products. Use ↑ ↓ to move through results.